Book Review



Under a Flaming Sky: The Great Hinckley Firestorm of 1894.  By: Daniel James Brown. The Lyons Press, 2006. ISBN-13: 978-1-59228-863-2. Pp. 256. $22.95
               
                Under a Flaming Sky is about a horrific firestorm that occurred on September 1, 1894 in the small town of Hinckley, Minnesota trapping nearly two thousand people.  Daniel Brown knew the stories of the Hinckley firestorm because his great-grandfather had died in the fire while his grandfather and great-grandmother escaped.  This book outlines the social, economic, and environmental causes of the disaster and also tells an assortment of survivor stories.  Brown explains the details of two firestorms converging together on the little town of Hinckley, Minnesota and the devastating impact it had on the people of the town.  With all the unreasonably dry weather and wildfires this year, I thought Under a Flaming Sky would be an interesting book to read and relate to since it occurred so close to home.
                Under a Flaming Sky is well written with daily accounts and fine detail that makes the reader feel like they are experiencing it first-hand.   Brown explains the Peshtigo fire in the autumn of 1871 allowing you to compare the events to come.  He describes peoples’ personal struggles that day with every gruesome detail.  Just when you think you need to put the book down to take a break, he eases the drama to explain forestry, logging history, and the differences between fire control then and now.  Following the prologue, Brown describes the events of the Hinckley fire in detail from his own research and the stories he has heard from survivors.  
                The book starts out describing conditions in other states that summer with unusually hot and dry weather and occasional fires breaking out.  So many small fires had occurred around Hinckley, that no one thought anything out of the ordinary because the fires never seemed to get large enough or out of control.  It is hard for us to relate to the people of Hinckley because we have access to satellite imagery, Doppler radar, and televised weather forecasts, while people in the nineteenth century just gazed skyward and tried to judge what kind of weather was in store.  Weather science in the 1890s was not always accurate and they found it very hard to predict unexpected storms especially wildfires.  He goes on to explain the day the firestorm occurred on September 1, 1894, introducing people in the town of Hinckley doing their daily routines unaware of what was about to come later that day.  Hinckley was a big logging town made possible by a tree called Pinus strobus or white pine.  White pine was ideal for making long masts on English sailing ships due to its lightweight but strong wood.   With the demand of wood from Europe, it was not so surprising that Hinckley flourished into a logging town.  In the midst of deforestation, persistent dry conditions, dry debris, and needle litter all over making it ideal for fires to spread quickly that day.
                Brown’s introduction was so fast-paced that it was hard to keep up with all the people he introduced and how they related to the story because he would jump back and forth between different stories and continued to do that throughout the whole book.  In chapter two, he describes how the fires continue to increase in strength as the strong winds pick up.  It went from small spot fires to jumping from lower branches and clawing their way up to the tops of trees.  Chapter four begins to explain the different classifications of wild land fires; ground fires, surface fires, and crown fires the latter of the 3 being the worst.  Brown does a good job of explaining the scientific detail of how fires are formed and what ignites them to a public audience.  Surprisingly enough, Hinckley came in second among all the fire departments west of Chicago at that time and was confident in their equipment and approach in extinguishing fires.  The firestorm just started to reach the town around 2:00 P.M.  The volunteer firefighters worked on extinguishing the fire, while the citizens watched convinced that the fire could not get past the firebreaks and railroad tracks into the heart of town.  Not long after though, the water pressure gave out from their hose and all the people of Hinckley could do was run and save themselves.  In less than a few hours, the fire ripped through and destroyed Hinckley.  All the citizens could do was run for their lives, hide in lakes or ponds, or try to make it to the next train coming through to save them.  Although even the trains had trouble escaping the storm where whole trains were engulfed in flames.  Not only did trains need to worry about spot fires, but bridges were burned down and the tracks were melting and becoming disfigured due to the 1600 degree heat.  
                One of the most gruesome, but interesting chapters is chapter eight in which it explains how being badly burned is about the worst thing that could happen to a body. Fully conscious victims, if they are surrounded by both flames and adequate oxygen, may remain alert until the flames have reached them and begun to consume their flesh, basically being burned alive.  No other type of injury causes such long-lasting physiological mayhem, pain, disfigurement, and uncertainty of the outcome.  If people were lucky enough to survive the fire, they now had to endure the pain of burn shock, the body beginning to basically cannibalize itself where the body burns calories at a furious rate because the body needs enormous amounts of fuel and oxygen.  This leads to the body being unable to fight off infections and microbial life begins to attack the burned victim.  It was just unbelievable to read what these burned victims had to endure not only with pain but with psychological affects after the disaster.
                The Hinckley fire consumed more than 300,000 acres including 5 smaller communities, namely Mission Creek, Sandstone, Miller, Partridge and Pokegama and also took more than 400 lives.  Once the fire had subsided, people that had heard of the fire through telegraphs, made their way towards Hinckley hoping to find survivors to help.  Hundreds of people are dead, many bodies are unidentifiable because they are basically ash, families are devastated of the loss of their family members and friends, entire towns are destroyed, livelihoods and possessions are lost.  Assistance is offered, but overall the timber industry was not regulated well, medicine that was available could not offer effective treatment, and they did not have counseling for post-traumatic events. People that survived basically just had to start over.  In the concluding chapter Brown explores the modern day town of Hinckley, Minnesota visiting memorial spots and the Hinckley Fire Museum.  History continues to repeat itself no matter how technologically advanced we become.  There will always be new natural disasters for people to endure.
                Overall, I would recommend this book to anyone who likes historical firestorm stories.  I could not put this book down especially while reading Brown’s detailed descriptions of the events which were well written and extremely interesting.  Although I did not care much for the personal stories throughout the book, the details of how the raging fire surrounded the town and consumed everything in its path made up for it.  I was not very knowledgeable of wildfires and did not realize how destructive and scary they could be until I read this book.  It gives you such insight into the destruction of this fire and the emotional and traumatic stories people had gone through.  Although it was overall a sad book to read, I now realize the true danger wildfires can have.

No comments:

Post a Comment